The Insurance Center of Milwaukee: The City’s Trusted, Independent Source for Insurance

We combine decades of insurance experience and local Milwaukee roots with the benefits of an independent agency. We are a member of the Big I of Wisconsin and work with more than a dozen insurers to offer a range of coverage at competitive prices.

Get a quick quote online, then call us or schedule an in-person meeting at our office or another convenient Milwaukee-area location. We can also handle service by phone, email or text, and we take the time to learn your circumstances and goals before recommending coverage. Learn more about why choose an independent agent.

Rich Tadych

An agent since 1992 with a background in Farmers Insurance, Rich became an independent agent to offer clients more coverage options. He has received several insurer awards and has supported local fundraising for the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation and the March of Dimes.

Jim Susedik

An agent since 1991, Jim has spent over 30 years helping customers insure their cars and homes. He has earned multiple awards, including a Five Star agent designation from Milwaukee Magazine in 2010. He entered insurance after a car accident sparked his interest, following a career in construction management.

Colleen Tadych

A licensed agent for more than 10 years, Colleen previously taught elementary school for 17 years. She is fluent in English and Spanish and holds degrees in education and English as a second language.

Scott Surprise

Scott has over 25 years of experience in health and Medicare insurance, including employee benefits for businesses. He served three years on active duty and 20 years in the U.S. Army Reserves. Contact: stinsurance14@gmail.com

Mary Faccidomo

A licensed agent for over 10 years, Mary focuses mainly on personal lines such as auto, home and umbrella coverage. She previously worked for Midwest Express airlines.

Michele Del Russi

Michele has a customer service and administrative background and became licensed in 2023. She works primarily with personal lines clients.

Contact: (414) 744-6614 | 3662 S Howell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207